|
* TinkerDifferent *
Retro Computing Community |
| Home | Forums | What's New | Search | Settings |
| Need solution for HDI-45 to DB-15 connectors for video out |
Forums > Vintage Apple > Macintosh > Beige PowerPC (Old World ROM) > NuBus-based Power Macintosh (6100, 7100, & 8100)
|
wottle Active Tinkerer Fort Mill, SC -------- Joined: Oct 30, 2021 Posts: 841 Likes: 577 |
Jan 2, 2025 - #1
OK, I've been working through my PowerMac 61xx machines that I picked up in my filthy haul a few weeks back. I've successfully built some replacement Y adapters for the ones with a DOS card, but I now have a bigger problem. I currently only have a single HDI-45 adapter that I had with my 6115CD. So I expect I'll have around ten 61xx machines when all is said and done and I'd like to be able to pass them along to others with most of what they need to connect to a monitor and use it (I won't have enough ADB keyboards either, but those are easier to come by / already have).
So, does anyone have a bunch of extras of these they'd be willing to sell, or better yet, has anyone figured out a way we can make a new adapter out of readily available parts? I saw a post oin 68kmla (https://68kmla.org/bb/index.php?threads/solutions-for-hdi45-to-vga-or-db15.39202/page-2) about the posibility of a PCB to get the right pin spacing and I love that idea, but I have no PCB design skills and doubt I could make one correctly. I was thinking of basically two PCBs. One that would mimic the pinout of the HDI-45 port. You would simply solder in the necessary pins, with wires soldered to the back side. a second PCB would accept those wires and have them go to a DB-15 port. A 3d printed case could hold both PCBs and provide a smaller replacement for all of us who are now missing adapters. Anyone have a similar need or have tackled this issue? |
|
wottle Active Tinkerer Fort Mill, SC -------- Joined: Oct 30, 2021 Posts: 841 Likes: 577 |
Jan 9, 2025 - #2
OK, so I think I may take a different approach. I think a more practical approach may be to build an adapter to mount a DB-15 port in the place of the HDI-45. It won't look as nice from the back, and you'd lose the ability to plug into that one AudioVision14 monitor, but I doubt many would care, and if you are one of the few with that monitor, you wouldn't need to do this replacement.
Anyway, so I was thinking of mocking up two boards (I don't think I can route all the traces and fit the through holes in the right spots to manage this with a single board. But there's room on the side of the connector, so I was thinking I'd make two boards, with seven 2mm spaced headers on each side. The bottom board would have pins for the HDI-45 connector on the logic board. The top board would have pin locations for a DB-15 connector. The pins on the side would simply transfer the signal between the two boards This would allow me to more easily route the traces. I actually looked at the spacing of the pins and it appears I might be able to fit the 2 rows of pins for the DB-15 connector in between rows of the HDI-45 connector, but I'm not sure that would leave me enough room for the traces... The pads for the holes might simply not allow for it. I'm hoping even with the extra height of the second board, the connector would still be low enough to fit through the opening of the existing hole for the HDI-45 connector. I'm planning on stumbling around in Eagle this weekend to see if I can mock up two versions. One using the two board approach, and another using the single board.
Liked by eric |
|
Trash80toG4 Active Tinkerer Bermuda Triangle, NC USA -------- Joined: Apr 1, 2022 Posts: 1,131 Likes: 329 |
Jan 9, 2025 - #3
I looked into this a loooong time ago for my 6100. What I came up with was a "periscope" PCB. with built in VGA adapter that mounts to the case with double sided tape or Velcro. *****
Never determined the pin spec for the HDI-45 monstrosity on the bottom of the board, likely header rows are available, but you really only need 15 pins, no? [Image: DSC_1451.JPG] Sorry about the oversize file, image editing workstation down ATM. Lucky here, the only NuBus PPC I really care about is my decked out Radius 81/110. With killer TPDs in their lineup, that beauty has DA-15 on board! ***** Neanderthal hacker that I am, washers, nuts and bolts would be employed. :p
Liked by ericandwottle |
|
phipli Tinkerer -------- Joined: Sep 23, 2021 Posts: 309 Likes: 215 |
Jan 9, 2025 - #4
It would be easier to desolder the connector from the logic board and replaced it with an L-shaped bracket that presented a standard apple or VGA port on the back. Way easier to pick up the contacts on the logic board than at the connector end.
Liked by Kai Robinsonanderic |
|
wottle Active Tinkerer Fort Mill, SC -------- Joined: Oct 30, 2021 Posts: 841 Likes: 577 |
Jan 9, 2025 - #5
The other challenge I need to figure out is making the add on board stable enough to handle the force of the connector being pushed in and pulled out repeatedly. Fortunately there are 4 ground connections on the corners that I'm hoping I can use to stabilize the board. |
|
Trash80toG4 Active Tinkerer Bermuda Triangle, NC USA -------- Joined: Apr 1, 2022 Posts: 1,131 Likes: 329 |
Jan 10, 2025 - #6
Since your stated purpose is to pass these machines along to other folks in the community, I think you might well reconsider my suggestion?
Some folks might want to keep the mobo cherry, some may want to keep the case cherry and some might want to pony up the bucks to source the real deal (gawdaweful as it may be) conversion cable from the ID10T crew at Apple. :rolleyes: In any case, they may wish to malign the case by drilling holes for bolting up the adapter I suggested to the backplane or deal with the foibles of sticky-tape/Velcro mounting to keep it bone stock or what not? In any case, KISS, reduce any modification to the machines to the minimum, avoiding the support of modifications to the machines at all costs. YMMV ;) |
|
phipli Tinkerer -------- Joined: Sep 23, 2021 Posts: 309 Likes: 215 |
Jan 10, 2025 - #7
I never drill holes in stuff I can't buy new, I tend to make new parts, but I don't consider removing a port as a permanent change. I could always put it back. Besides... lets be honest, it is an improvement. Almost nobody wants a HDI45 connector on their 6100. Obviously ignoring the scruffy PCB traces that I'm not going to spend ages sketching in any reasonable way. I should have drawn the triangles key'd through the base PCB into the ground points on the logic board. But I didn't.
|
|
Trash80toG4 Active Tinkerer Bermuda Triangle, NC USA -------- Joined: Apr 1, 2022 Posts: 1,131 Likes: 329 |
Jan 10, 2025 - #8
You don't need the vertical members for such a design. Use Right Angle HD-15 connector and build the VGA conversion into your board. Gotta pop the top to flip the switches, but that's easy on the pop-top 6100.
A lot of folks want to keep the logic boards intact, some would gladly pony up the bucks for that ridonkulous Apple conversion cable. Desoldering the connector to solder an internal adapter board would be a lot of work for wottle to pass machines on from his newly acquired Moras-o-Macs. ;) @wottle avoid using a Mac DA-15 connector at all costs. Definitely don't want to hang a VGA Adapter off any internal adaptation, strain relief nightmares to be had there. |
|
Trash80toG4 Active Tinkerer Bermuda Triangle, NC USA -------- Joined: Apr 1, 2022 Posts: 1,131 Likes: 329 |
Jan 10, 2025 - #9
Yer killin' me here guys! :p Just had to pull the 6100 board to see what's going on. There's plenty of clearance for a horizontal PCB with RA HD-15 VGA connector to pop out the back. There's even a handy bolt-down hole right next to the highest IC to be cleared behind the connector.
If the IC is still too high, just have a hole or notch in the PCB for it to pop its head aboveboard. Looks good for any hot air rework station/soldering iron jockey. |
|
phipli Tinkerer -------- Joined: Sep 23, 2021 Posts: 309 Likes: 215 |
Jan 10, 2025 - #10
I don't quite know what chips you're talking about though, isn't it just the HDI-45 connector going on between the board edge and the connector pins? |
|
Nycturne Tinkerer -------- Joined: Dec 18, 2024 Posts: 98 Likes: 62 |
Jan 10, 2025 - #11
ICs on the 6100 logic board. If your goal is to build a PCB that will go straight to VGA, you will need the adapter logic built in, and thus some space is needed to fit it all in. I think they are commenting it should be straight forward to let the PCB sit above the ICs if you need the space. |
|
phipli Tinkerer -------- Joined: Sep 23, 2021 Posts: 309 Likes: 215 |
Jan 10, 2025 - #12
|
|
Nycturne Tinkerer -------- Joined: Dec 18, 2024 Posts: 98 Likes: 62 |
Jan 10, 2025 - #13
To me, that's still adapter logic (perhaps circuit is more precise). Even the old ones didn't exactly have much in the way of smarts.
But ultimately, the comment was that there should be plenty of room to do whatever you need with a PCB, as it should be straight-forward to work around the ICs on the logic board if needed. |
|
Trash80toG4 Active Tinkerer Bermuda Triangle, NC USA -------- Joined: Apr 1, 2022 Posts: 1,131 Likes: 329 |
Jan 10, 2025 - #14
You'll want to make the PCB about 50mm deep and about 35mm wide so it reaches the handy bolt down/standoff hole behind at the right edge of the connector. housing
. . . ______ ___| . .. 0 | <- standoff/boltdown | . . . . . . . | | . . . . . . . | |_________| <- rear of case |
|
wottle Active Tinkerer Fort Mill, SC -------- Joined: Oct 30, 2021 Posts: 841 Likes: 577 |
Jan 11, 2025 - #15
Appreciate the guidance. While I do agree that a VGA output would be ideal, 1. I'm not sure how you'd connect traces on PCBs at a right angle. Pads that line up at the edge of each board? I may see if I can make up a board that simply gives me a DB-15 connector and I'll use the adapter. Also, it allows me to still use my Dos Compatible card. It's fully reversible and it will be easier to remove since I will only be soldering a fraction of the pins.
Also, I don't plan on doing this for all the machines I'm going to be offloading (I expect I'll have about 8), but I want to at least have a solution for the one I plan to keep (one of the DOS Compatible ones). And if I can make the adapters pretty easily, I can at least give them to the new owner to install if they want. Or I could probably install them for a bit extra (removing that HDI-45 connector was a bear). If I cannot make all the pins work on the single board adapter, I may look into the 90 degree board assembly, along with possibly making a VGA output version. Or possibly go back to my original idea, which was a plug in adapter that would leave the logic board fully untouched. I just don't believe I have the 3d modeling skills to make it work. We'll see, but with that, it would be easy to make two versions, one with the VGA/SVGA conversion, and one without. I will say, I played around with the Quadra 650 with the older 58x Reply card and it was so much nicer to be able to simply plug it into the DB-15 port without the adapter. I need to look into what other machines the Houdini II cards can work in... |
|
NJRoadfan New Tinkerer -------- Joined: Feb 6, 2022 Posts: 75 Likes: 21 |
Jan 11, 2025 - #16
I'd solder on a PCB directly on top of the footprint of the removed HDI-45, just push the pins directly into the holes on the board and use any lugs to stabilize it. It'll likely be a double sided board depending on the pin routing. There may be enough room to direct mount a right angle VGA HDI-15 to the board as well.
Liked by wottleandNycturne |
|
wottle Active Tinkerer Fort Mill, SC -------- Joined: Oct 30, 2021 Posts: 841 Likes: 577 |
Jan 11, 2025 - #17
|
|
phipli Tinkerer -------- Joined: Sep 23, 2021 Posts: 309 Likes: 215 |
Jan 11, 2025 - #18
|
|
Nycturne Tinkerer -------- Joined: Dec 18, 2024 Posts: 98 Likes: 62 |
Jan 11, 2025 - #19
You don't know my background, and I don't know yours, so can we chill with jumping down each other's throats here? I only jumped in to clarify someone else's argument, and I'm being made to feel like I'm now making that argument. This is a rabbit hole that only serves to pull away from the original idea from the other poster: *IF* you need the space, the space is there. Yes, I didn't use precise language here, which I already admitted, so please just take a breath. |
|
phipli Tinkerer -------- Joined: Sep 23, 2021 Posts: 309 Likes: 215 |
Jan 11, 2025 - #20
I was sharing thoughts because it is something I've considered doing to my 6100 and / or 8100. I really hate the HDI45 adapters. Unrelated, but Apple were putting the HDI-45 on the dual 601 CPU prototype that they cancelled - the tesseract project that the PDM / 6100 and family was the fallback for.
Liked by ClassicHasClassandNycturne |
| Page 1 of 7 | Next > | Last >> |
| Home | Forums | What's New | Search | Bookmarks | RSS | Original | Settings |
| XenForo Retro Proxy by TinkerDifferent.com |